Saturday, February 25, 2017

19th-century Jeweled Imitations at the British Museum

Luigi and Raffaele Angelo Marchi of Bologna
Pendant - imitating painted pendant in
Raphael's altarpiece of St Cecilia

ca. 1898-1902
enameled gold, chalcedony, pearl
British Museum

The jewel above was created in Bologna at the end of the 19th century in response to a painting (below) still on display today in Bologna, exactly 500 years after it was created. St Cecilia in the center of the panel wears the pendant against the dark border of her bodice.

Raphael
Ecstasy of St Cecilia
1516-17
oil on panel, transferred to canvas
Pinacoteca Nazionale di Bologna

The Marchi brothers fabricated their imitation openly, with no wish to conceal its origins as a product of their own time and place. This was not true of the 19th-century European jewelers who fabricated the intricate Renaissance-style pendants below. As late as the 1980s, most of these were accepted and displayed as genuine 16th-century pieces. They had been purchased at premium prices by members of the Rothschild family, who ultimately donated them with great pomp of generosity to the British Museum. Recent, more cautious analysis  along with art-historical evidence  revealed both small and large anomalies of materials and construction and caused their current demotion to the status of more-or-less skillful forgeries.

Anonymous Spanish Jeweler
Pendant - Hippocamp
19th century imitating 16th century
enameled gold, emerald, pearl
British Museum

Anonymous European Jeweler
Pendant - Monstrous Fish
19th century imitating 16th century
enameled gold, emerald, ruby, garnet, amethyst, pearl
British Museum

Anonymous French Jeweler
Pendant - Vase-shape
19th century imitating 16th century
enameled gold, sapphire, garnet, pearl
British Museum

Anonymous French Jeweler
Pendant - Sea Dragon
19th century imitating 16th century
enameled gold, pearl
British Museum

Anonymous German Jeweler
Pendant - Venus on shell
19th century imitating 16th century
enameled gold, ruby, sapphire, diamond, pearl
British Museum

Anonymous French Jeweler
Pendant - Venus and Cupid
19th century imitating 16th century
enameled gold, ruby, diamond, pearl
British Museum

Anonymous Hungarian Jeweler
Pendant - Hawk
19th century imitating 16th century
enameled gold, ruby, diamond, pearl
British Museum

Anonymous French Jeweler
Pendant - Charity with children
19th century imitating 16th century
enameled gold, ruby, emerald, diamond, pearl
British Museum

Anonymous French Jeweler
Pendant - Couchant Hind
19th century imitating 16th century
enameled gold, ruby, pearl
British Museum

Anonymous European Jeweler
Pendant - Mermaid
19th century imitating 16th century
enameled gold, emerald, pearl
British Museum

Anonymous French Jeweler
Pendant - Cleopatra
19th century imitating 16th century
enameled gold, sapphire, ruby, emerald, pearl
British Museum

Anonymous German Jeweler
Pendant - Galloping horse and warrior
16th century, altered in the 19th century
enameled gold, ruby, emerald, pearl
British Museum

Anonymous Italian Jeweler
Pendant - Hippocamp
16th century, altered in the 19th century
enameled gold, ruby, emerald, pearl
British Museum